Nudges: a promising behavioral public policy tool to reduce vaccine hesitancy

Alejandro Hortal

Resumo


Although vaccines are considered an efficient public health tool by medical experts, in different countries, people’s confidence in them has been decreasing. COVID-19 has elevated medical scientists’ and practitioners’ social reputation, and it may have reduced global vaccination hesitancy. Still, this alone will not altogether remove the existent frictions that prevent people from complying with vaccination schedules. This paper will review the common causes behind vaccination hesitancy. It will also explore different types of public policy interventions that health experts in governments and institutions employ to fight vaccine hesitancy and non-compliance. The main objective of this article is to argue that, considering the nature of the issue (vaccine hesitancy and its causes), among the various possibilities, policies based on behavioral insights can provide an effective instrument to remove those frictions. Among them, special attention will be devoted to nudges which promise efficiency while avoiding some of the ethical and political costs of other interventions, thanks to their libertarian paternalistic frame. The article concludes by suggesting that public health policymakers should consider the libertarian paternalistic approach of nudges when deploying interventions that aim at changing people’s attitudes and behavior.

Palavras-chave


Vaccine Hesitancy, Nudge Theory, Public Health, Decision Theory, Behavioral Public Policy, Libertarian Paternalism

Texto completo:

PDF (English)

Referências


AFOLABI, Aanuoluwapo Adeyimika; ILESANMI, Olayinka Stephen. Dealing with vaccine hesitancy in Africa: the prospective COVID-19 vaccine context. The Pan African Medical Journal, v. 38, p. 3, 2021.

ÁLVAREZ, J. Francisco. El tejido de la racionalidad acotada y expresiva. Manuscrito, v. XXV, n. 2, p. 11–29, 2002.

BANERJEE, A. V.; DUFLO, E.; GLENNERSTER, R.; KOTHARI, D. Improving immunization coverage in rural India: a clustered randomized controlled evaluation of immunization campaigns with and without incentives. British Medical Journal, v. 340, n. C2220, 2010.

BAUTISTA BALBÁS, Luis Alfredo; CONESA, Mario Gil; BALBÁS, Blanca Bautista; JIMÉNEZ, Ainhoa Alcaide; RODRÍGUEZ CARAVACA, Gil. COVID-19 immunization threshold(s): an analysis. MedRxiv, 2021.

BICCHIERI, Cristina. Norms in the wild: how to diagnose, measure, and change social norms. Oxford University Press, 2017.

BRUCE, Lori; TALLMAN, Ruth. Promoting racial equity in COVID-19 resource allocation. Journal of Medical Ethics, 2021.

CALLAGHAN, Timothy; MOGHTADERI, Ali; LUECK, Jennifer A.; HOTEZ, Peter J.; STRYCH, Ulrich; DOR, Avi; FRANKLIN FOWLER, Erika; MOTTA, Matt. Correlates and disparities of COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy. SSRN Electronic Journal, 2020.

CARTWRIGHT, Nancy; HARDIE, Jeremy. Evidence-based policy: a practical guide to doing it better: Oxford University Press, 2012.

CHASE, Brett; MALAGÓN, Elvia. Chicago vaccine distribution: few on South Side, West Side get COVID shots so far. Chicago Sun-Times, 2020.

DOBBIN, Frank; KALEV, Alexandra. Why diversity programs fail. Harvard Business Review, 2016.

DUBÉ, Eve; LABERGE, Caroline; GUAY, Maryse; BRAMADAT, Paul; ROY, Réal; BETTINGER, Julie. Vaccine hesitancy: an overview. Human vaccines & immunotherapeutics, v. 9, n. 8, p. 1763–1773, 2013.

EKWEBELEM, O. C.; YUNUSA, I.; ONYEAKA, H.; EKWEBELEM, N. C.; NNOROM-DIKE, O. COVID-19 vaccine rollout: will it affect the rates of vaccine hesitancy in Africa? Public Health, 2021.

EPTON, Tracy; CURRIE, Sinead; ARMITAGE, Christopher J. Unique effects of setting goals on behavior change: systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, v. 85, n. 12, p. 1182–1198, 2017.

ESSHAKI, E. The Affordable Care Act, experience rating, and the problem of non-vaccination. U. Mich. JL Reform Caveat, v. 49, 2015.

GAMBLE, V. N. Under the shadow of Tuskegee: African Americans and health care. American Journal of Public Health, v. 87, n. 11, p. 1773–1778, 1997.

GERBER, Jeffrey S.; OFFIT, Paul A. Vaccines and autism: a tale of shifting hypotheses. Clinical Infectious Diseases, v. 48, n. 4, p. 456–461, 2009.

GIGERENZER, Gerd. On the supposed evidence for libertarian paternalism. Review of Philosophy and Psychology, v. 6, n. 3, p. 361–383, 2015.

GIUBILINI, Alberto; SAVULESCU, Julian. Vaccination, risks, and freedom: the seat belt analogy. Public Health Ethics, v. 12, n. 3, p. 237–249, 2019.

GIUBILINI, Alberto et al. Nudging immunity: the case for vaccinating children in school and day care by default. HEC forum: an interdisciplinary journal on hospitals’ ethical and legal issues, v. 31, n. 4, p. 325–344, 2019.

GRÅD, Erik; ERLANDSSON, Arvid; TINGHÖG, Gustav. Do nudges crowd out prosocial behavior? Behavioural Public Policy, p. 1–14, 2021.

GRIGNOLIO, Andrea. Vaccines: Are they worth a shot? Springer International Publishing, 2018. ISBN: 978-3-319-68105-4.

HENDRIX, Kristin S.; STURM, Lynne A.; ZIMET, Gregory D.; MESLIN, Eric M. Ethics and childhood vaccination policy in the United States. American Journal of Public Health, v. 106, n. 2, p. 273–278, 2016.

HERTWIG, Ralph; GRÜNE-YANOFF, Till. Nudging and boosting: Steering or empowering good decisions. Perspectives on Psychological Science, v. 12, n. 6, p. 973–986, 2017.

HORTAL, Alejandro. Nudging and Educating: Bounded Axiological Rationality in Behavioral Insights. Behavioural Public Policy, v. 4, n. 3, p. 292–315, 2020.

HUETE, Cristina; LINDE, Pablo. Coronavirus: Galicia, primera comunidad en prever multas por no vacunarse. Sociedad. EL PAÍS. 2021.

KORN, Lars; BETSCH, Cornelia; BÖHM, Robert; MEIER, Nicolas W. Social nudging: the effect of social feedback interventions on vaccine uptake. Health Psychology, v. 37, n. 11, p. 1045–1054, 2018.

LARSON, H.; DE FIGUEIREDO, A.; KARAFILLAKIS, E.; RAWAL, M. State of vaccine confidence in the EU 2018. Luxembourg: European Commission, 2018.

LARSON, Heidi J.; JARRETT, Caitlin; ECKERSBERGER, Elisabeth; SMITH, David M. D.; PATERSON, Pauline. Understanding vaccine hesitancy around vaccines and vaccination from a global perspective: a systematic review of published literature, 2007-2012. Vaccine, v. 32, n. 19, p. 2150–2159, 2014.

LAZARUS, Jeffrey V.; RATZAN, Scott C.; PALAYEW, Adam; GOSTIN, Lawrence O.; LARSON, Heidi J.; RABIN, Kenneth; KIMBALL, Spencer; EL-MOHANDES, Ayman. A global survey of potential acceptance of a COVID-19 vaccine. Nature Medicine, v. 27, n. 2, p. 225–228, 2021.

LEHMANN, Birthe A.; CHAPMAN, Gretchen B.; FRANSSEN, Frits M. E.; KOK, Gerjo; RUITER, Robert A. C. Changing the default to promote influenza vaccination among health care workers. Vaccine, v. 34, n. 11, p. 1389–1392, 2016.

LEIGHT, Jessica; SAFRAN, Elana. Increasing immunization compliance among schools and day care centers: evidence from a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Behavioral Public Administration, v. 2, n. 2, 2019.

MACDONALD, Noni E.; HARMON, Shawn; DUBE, Eve; STEENBEEK, Audrey; CROWCROFT, Natasha; OPEL, Douglas J.; FAOUR, David; LEASK, Julie; BUTLER, Robb. Mandatory Infant & Childhood Immunization: Rationales, issues and knowledge gaps. Vaccine, v. 36, n. 39, p. 5811–5818, 2018.

MACFARQUHAR, Neil. Far-right extremists move from ‘stop the steal’ to stop the vaccine. The New York Times, 2021.

MALIK, Amyn A.; MCFADDEN, SarahAnn M.; ELHARAKE, Jad; OMER, Saad B. Determinants of COVID-19 vaccine acceptance in the US. EClinicalMedicine, v. 26, 2020.

MATJASKO, Jennifer L.; CAWLEY, John H.; BAKER-GOERING, Madeleine M.; YOKUM, David V. Applying behavioral economics to public health policy: illustrative examples and promising directions. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, v. 50, n. 5 Suppl 1, p. S13–S19, 2016.

MAYS, Mackenzie. From anti-vax to anti-mask: school districts brace for parent resistance. Politico, 2020. Disponível em: https://www.politico.com/states/california/story/2020/07/02/from-anti-vax-to-anti-mask-school-districts-brace-for-parent-resistance-1295968. Acesso em: 6 jul. 2020.

MCKENNA, Kyle Christopher. Use of aborted fetal tissue in vaccines and medical research obscures the value of all human life. The Linacre Quarterly, v. 85, n. 1, p. 13–17, 2018.

MCNEIL, Donald. Covid-19: How much herd immunity is enough? The New York Times, 2020.

MELLSTRÖM, Carl; JOHANNESSON, Magnus. Crowding out in blood donation: was Titmuss right? Journal of the European Economic Association, v. 6, n. 4, p. 845–863, 2008.

MILKMAN, K. L.; PATEL, M. S.; GANDHI, L.; et al. A megastudy of text-based nudges encouraging patients to get vaccinated at an upcoming doctor’s appointment. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, v. 118, n. 20, 2021.

NAVIN, Mark. Values and vaccine refusal: hard questions in ethics, epistemology, and health care. Routledge, 2015.

NAVIN, Mark C. The ethics of vaccination nudges in pediatric practice. HEC forum: an interdisciplinary journal on hospitals’ ethical and legal issues, v. 29, n. 1, p. 43–57, 2017.

NORC UNIV. OF CHIC. Expectations for a COVID-19 vaccine. APNORC.org. The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research, 2020. Disponível em: http://www.apnorc.org/projects/Pages/Expectations-for-a-COVID-19-Vaccine.aspx. Acesso em: 9 jul. 2020.

OLIVER, Adam. From nudging to budging: using behavioural economics to inform public sector policy. Journal of social policy, v. 42, n. 04, p. 685–700, 2013.

OLIVER, Adam. The origins of behavioural public policy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2017.

OLIVER, Adam. Nudges, shoves and budges: behavioural economic policy frameworks. The International Journal of Health Planning and Management, v. 33, n. 1, p. 272–275, 2018.

OLIVER, Adam. Reciprocity and the art of behavioural public policy. Cambridge University Press, 2019.

OPEL, Douglas J.; OMER, Saad B. Measles, mandates, and making vaccination the default option. JAMA Pediatrics, v. 169, n. 4, p. 303–304, 2015.

PARKS, Miles. Misleading facts fuel COVID-19 misinformation, evade social media moderation. NPR. National Public Radio, 2021.

PATEL, Mitesh. Test behavioural nudges to boost COVID immunization. Nature, v. 590, n. 185, 2021.

PERKINS, Rebecca B.; FISHER-BORNE, Marcie; BREWER, Noel T. Engaging parents around vaccine confidence: proceedings from the national HPV vaccination roundtable meetings. Human vaccines & immunotherapeutics, v. 15, n. 7–8, p. 1639–1640, 2019.

RAO, Suchitra; NYQUIST, Ann-Christine. The power of the nudge to decrease decision fatigue and increase influenza vaccination rates. JAMA Network Open, v. 1, n. 5, 2018.

REIJULA, Samuli; HERTWIG, RALPH. Self-nudging and the citizen choice architect. Behavioural Public Policy, p. 1–31, 2020.

REIJULA, Samuli; KUORIKOSKI, Jaakko; EHRIG, Timo; KATSIKOPOULOS, Konstantinos; SUNDER, Shyam. Nudge, boost, or design? Limitations of behaviorally informed policy under social interaction. Journal of Behavioral Economics for Policy, Vol. 2, No. 1, 99-105, 2018.

SALLAM, Malik et al. High Rates of COVID-19 Vaccine hesitancy and its association with conspiracy beliefs: a study in Jordan and Kuwait among other Arab countries. Vaccines, v. 9, n. 1, 2021.

SEDLMEIER, P.; GIGERENZER, G. Teaching Bayesian reasoning in less than two hours. J. Exp. Psychol. Gen., v. 130, n. 3, p. 380–400, 2001.

SHAPIRO, Gilla K.; TATAR, Ovidiu; DUBE, Eve; AMSEL, Rhonda; KNAUPER, Barbel; NAZ, Anila; PEREZ, Samara; ROSBERGER, Zeev. The vaccine hesitancy scale: psychometric properties and validation. Vaccine, v. 36, n. 5, p. 660–667, 2018.

SIMON, Herbert. Models of bounded rationality, Volume 1: Economic Analysis And Public Policy. 1. ed., Cambridge, Mass: The MIT Press, 1982. p. 392.

SMITH, Philip J.; SANTOLI, Jeanne M.; CHU, Susan Y.; OCHOA, Dianne Q.; RODEWALD, Lance E. The association between having a medical home and vaccination coverage among children eligible for the vaccines for children program. Pediatrics, v. 116, n. 1, p. 130–139, 2005.

SOUZA, L. C.; RAMOS, K. T. F.; PERDIGÃO, S. C. R. V. Análise crítica da orientação de cidadãos como método para otimizar decisões públicas por meio da técnica nudge. Revista Brasileira de Políticas Públicas, v. 8, n. 2. 2018.

SUNSTEIN, Cass R. Nudges vs. shoves. Harvard Law Review Forum, v. 127, p. 210, 2013.

SUNSTEIN, Cass R. Behavioral science and public policy. Cambridge University Press, 2020.

THALER, Richard H.; SUNSTEIN, Cass R. Nudge: improving decisions about health, wealth and happiness. Penguin, 2009.

TVERSKY, A.; KAHNEMAN, D. Judgment under uncertainty: heuristics and biases. Science, v. 185, n. 4157, p. 1124–1131, 1974.

VAN BAVEL, Jay J. et al. Using social and behavioural science to support covid-19 pandemic response. Nature Human Behaviour, v. 4, n. 5, p. 460–471, 2020.

VENEMA, Tina A. G.; KROESE, Floor M.; DE VET, Emely; DE RIDDER, Denise T. D. The One that I want: strong personal preferences render the center-stage nudge redundant. Food Quality and Preference, v. 78, 2019.

WALTER, Dror; OPHIR, Yotam; JAMIESON, Kathleen Hall. Russian Twitter accounts and the partisan polarization of vaccine discourse, 2015-2017. American Journal of Public Health, v. 110, n. 5, p. 718–724, 2020.

WILKINSON, T. M. Nudging and manipulation. Political Studies, v. 61, n. 2, p. 341–355, 2013.

WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION, WHO. Improving vaccination demand and addressing hesitancy. 2020. Disponível em: https://www.who.int/immunization/programmes_systems/vaccine_hesitancy/en/. Acesso em: 21 jun. 2020.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.5102/rbpp.v12i1.7993

ISSN 2179-8338 (impresso) - ISSN 2236-1677 (on-line)

Desenvolvido por:

Logomarca da Lepidus Tecnologia